Explainer · 3 min 31 s
317L vs 316L: what the extra molybdenum buys
317L vs 316L: both seamless austenitic pipe to the same standards. The step is molybdenum, and one point of it is 3.3 PREN.
- Format
- Explainer
- Published
- Duration
- 3 min 31 sec
- Language
- English
About this video
This explainer is educational. It separates the L (a carbon limit that answers welding) from the molybdenum (the chloride screening step), uses the published screening order and IMOA's PREN formula, and leaves the measured chemistry to the EN 10204 type 3.1 certificate. PREN is a screening number, not a corrosion test; confirm grade, standard, size, tests and documents on the quotation for each order.
Chapters
Each chapter opens the video at that point on YouTube.
- 0:00
317L vs 316L: what the extra molybdenum buys
317L vs 316L: same mill, same size, same test record. One carries more molybdenum in the steel. What does that buy?
- 0:10
317L vs 316L: same mill, same size, different chemistry
316L is S31603, and 317L is S31703. Both are seamless austenitic pipe, ordered to A312, A213, A269 or A376. A tape cannot tell them apart. The difference is in the chemistry.
- 0:34
Why 316L is the baseline: low carbon, 2–3 % molybdenum
316L is the baseline: low carbon, and 2 to 3 percent molybdenum. The low carbon answers welding. It does not answer pitting in chloride. So ask what the extra molybdenum answers, not which grade is better. In chloride service, the attack starts at the wall. Chloride, oxygen, pH, velocity, stagnation and cleaning: the published service list. Add design temperature, and the piping code that governs the line. None of that is in the grade name.
- 1:04
Where 317L fits: screening order, molybdenum and PREN
The catalogue's own screening order puts 317L second, after 316L. The question there is whether more alloying answers the corrosion concern you found. If it does not, the next rung is 904L or 254SMO, compared at the relevant temperature. 347H is the fourth question: creep at temperature, not chloride. Here is what the published ranges say about molybdenum. 316L is specified from 2.0 to 3.0 percent. 904L from 4 to 5. 254SMO from 6 to 6.5. 317L sits between 316L and 904L in that order. Its own range comes from the standard you order, and from the certificate. PREN turns that chemistry into one screening number. Chromium, plus 3.3 times molybdenum and half the tungsten, plus 16 times nitrogen. Hold chromium and nitrogen still, and one more point of molybdenum adds 3.3. So the step is real. It is also measured, and it is not a corrosion test.
- 2:13
One mill route, and the certificate that carries the chemistry
Cold drawing pulls the tube through a die, over a fixed mandrel. The wall thins and the bore is set. Both grades run it. The grade is decided before the route starts. Then 6 pickling systems, 4 straightening machines, and a saw that sets the length. 7 test groups check what comes off the line. Two offers can still differ on wall basis, finish, hold time and test calibration. The number that separates them is not written on the pipe. It is in the mill test certificate: the measured analysis of that heat. A PREN requirement with no data basis is ambiguous. Say whether it applies to the standard minimums or to the heat analysis.
- 2:55
How to write a 317L or 316L order line
So the order carries more than a grade. Product and form, standard and edition, size and wall basis. Quantity, condition, inspection, delivery, and whether alternatives may be proposed. Written that way, two offers can be compared line by line. The size is written in millimetres. The grade is written in one word. The certificate closes the gap between them. Send the size, the grade and the document, and the pipe can be confirmed instead of assumed. Send the grade, the standard, the size and the failure you are solving, and we confirm the pipe and its documents.
Specify the pipe or tube for your project
Send the grade, standard, OD × wall × length, wall basis, quantity, inspection and documents with your enquiry.
